A conservative film maker has undertaken a massive effort to show that President Obama's real father was a Communist, not Barack Obama, Sr.
Joel Gilbert, left, has mailed hundreds of thousands of free copies of his film, Dreams from My Real Father, to news outlets and ordinary households across the United States to stimulate interest in its themes.
“All evidence points to a sham marriage to cover an illicit affair between Ann Dunham and Frank Marshall Davis,” said the movie maker last month at a conference I attended at the National Press Club. “All evidence indicates that Barack Obama was raised and indoctrinated by Frank Marshall Davis, a Communist Party USA propagandist, during his formative years.”
Gilbert was a guest on the Aug. 23 edition of MTL Washington Update, the weekly public affairs radio show I co-host at noon (EDT) with network founder Scott Draughon. Click here to listen to the show, which is available by archive after live broadcast.
Gilbert is a film director, writer, and musician. Through his production company, Highway 61 Entertainment, Gilbert directed and produced four documentary feature films on Bob Dylan's music and career. Gilbert appeared in these films as interviewer, and performs on the film soundtracks.As part of his promotion efforts for his film, he spoke July 19 at the annual American Survival conference organized by ultra-conservative Cliff Kincaid, with this year's primary focus on what it claimed were the president's links to radical Islam.
I attended the conference, met most of the speakers, and collected nearly all of their their materials. One was a new book by Paul Kengor, The Communist: Frank Marshall Davis: The Untold Story of Barack Obama's Mentor.
During the Aug. 23 show, we have a lively and probing discussion. After the segment expired we have several remaining questions. Gilbert followed up by email with this Q &A:
Q: Why does Paul Kengor call Davis an Obama "mentor" and you a "father?"
Gilbert: Paul Kengor and I both agree that Obama began visits to Frank Marshall Davis' house from age nine.This is also supported by Obama in his book, Dreams from My Father, as well as interviews with Davis' neighbors.
I believe the often-repeated idea -- that Obama's grandfather, Stanley Dunham, felt Obama needed a Black mentor, so he chose Frank Marshall Davis to help him with Black Identity -- is nonsense. The only source of this misinformation was Obama's half-sister. She gave this story regarding Davis in the 2008 campaign regarding Obama's so-called teenage identity crisis of Black and White, which was alleged by David Axelrod. Meanwhile, Obama's best friend Keith Kakagauwa ("Ray" in Dreams from My Father) has said there was no identity crisis, "not even close".
My analysis is as follows: Barry Obama was a multi-racial kid, entering a multi-racial society (Hawaii) at 9 years old. The plausibility of Gramps deciding Obama needed a Black mentor in this scenario is about zero. And Davis, a 65-year old Communist pornographer, was a hard-core Marxist and not a typical African American by any means. The history is that Ann Dunham dropped off Barry in Hawaii and headed back to Indonesia. What are the chances she said to Gramps, "Remember that pornographer, the 65-year-old Communist I took naked photos in the fall of 1960? I want Barry to be raised by this guy while I'm away."
This could only make sense if Davis was the father. We have a lot of evidence supporting the visits as paternal visits. We have evidence of an intimate relationship between Dunham and Davis, while it's been proven that Obama's story of his parents is false, and there is no evidence the Kenyan ever married or even met Ann Dunham.
Q: How could you afford to mail out all of those copies of the film across the United States? How can you be so sure that photos purported to be of the president's mother at the home of Davis were actually of her, and not fabricated composites by current political enemies of the president?
Gilbert: See this article by Jerome Corsi for my quotes and references.
Q: How do "Birther" proponents who claim that Obama was born in Kenya react to this film? More specifically, what about World Net Daily, for example, which also employs columnist Jerome Corsi, author of the 2011 book, Where's the Birth Certificate?
Corsi and many others have agreed that Davis is the likely the father, and everyone agrees the Kenyan is definetly not the father.
Q: What is your view of those in the conventional news media who self-censor or disparage those who address this kind of controversial topic?
See this link, and read the transcript.
As further context, the following are excerpts from a Frequently Asked Questions handout Gilbert distributed at the conference.
How did you come to investigate President Obama's life history?
I have a background in Middle East and Islamic studies and in 2010 wrote and directed a film called Atomic Jihad: Ahmadinejad's Coming War and Obama's Politics of Defeat. While reviewing video of over 200 Obama speeches for that film, I noticed an odd pattern. When speaking of issues relating to the rich and the poor, Obama became very excited, speaking rapidly and louder, always in a higher pitch. On other subjects, he was quite calm. Why would Obama have an inner passion for class struggle? From my knowledge of his background, exclusive prep school, Ivy Leagues, Harvard Law -- it didn't seem to fit. I then read his autobiography, Dreams from My Father, and noticed numerous references to Obama seeking out Marxist professors and friends, emulating Malcolm X, attending socialist conferences, and organizing. It was a life journey in socialism! Plus, of his visits to Communist Frank Marshall Davis' house with his grandfather, Obama wrote, "It was as if I were witnessing some complicated, unspoken transaction between the two men."
I decided to investigate Frank Marshall Davis. His close physical resemblance to Obama was shocking, while Obama little resembled the Kenyan Obama. How could this be? Next, I unearthed two film archives of Frank Marshall Davis, one from 1973, the other from 1987, as well as Davis' photo collection. I then acquired 500 copies of the Honolulu Record, the Communist run newspaper where Davis wrote a weekly political column for eight years. I also obtained seven indecent photos of Ann Dunham, Obama's mother, taken at Frank Marshall Davis' house, suggesting an intimate connection between Dunham and Davis. I concluded that to understand Obama’s plans for America, the question was "Who is the real father?"
How does your "Dreams" film compare to Obama's autobiography?
My Dreams provides the first cohesive understanding of Obama's deep rooted life journey in socialism. It includes Obama's indoctrination in Marxism by Frank Marshall Davis, his college years, his job as "organizer," his involvement with Project Vote and the sub-prime mortgage crisis, the Ayers family, Alinsky and Reverend Wright, all the way to his campaigns and Presidency. Dreams from My Real Father is an alternate theory to Barack Obama's autobiography. The film narrative is based on both new and existing factual pillars, then presents reasoned logic, re-creations of probable events, and speculation for a complete story. Some dialogue is taken directly from Davis and Obama's writings, while some is approximated to bridge known facts. Viewers must judge the story for themselves. I believe they will agree that my "Dreams" is closer to reality than Obama's account, which more resembles a fairy tale.
In 2007, Gilbert released a controversial political documentary called, Farewell Israel: Bush, Iran and the Revolt of Islam, a history of Islamic-Jewish relations from the 7th Century to today. Gilbert's 2010 release entitled, Atomic Jihad: Ahmadinejad's Coming War for Islamic Revival and Obama's Politics of Defeat, was featured at the CPAC Conference in Washington D.C. and was a winning film at the Hudson Institute Film Festival in New York City on May 31, 2010.
Related News Coverage
World Net Daily, See the Man Who Challenges Obama's Family Story, Bob Unruh, July 17, 2012. A filmmaker whose full-length documentary, “Dreams from My Real Father,” presents a compelling case that Communist Party USA propagandist Frank Marshall Davis is Barack Obama’s biological father, is challenging the U.S. media to begin reporting the truth about the likely Democrat nominee for president in 2012. Joel Gilbert, whose website details his research, appeared recently at the National Press Club in Washington to talk about the questions raised in his film. “What strikes me as most disturbing is that any one of the hundreds of American journalists in this building could win the Pulitzer Prize just by writing about the evidence presented in ‘Dreams from My Real Father,’” he said. A journalist, after all, is supposed to report the news, truthfully and fairly, he argues. He said that American journalists have been in the pocket of the Obama campaign and administration, in violation of those precepts for journalists. “I accuse ABC, NBC, and CBS network news divisions of violating the public trust by refusing to cover my documentary film and for ignoring all the revelations about Obama’s background that other researchers have produced,” he said. “I accuse MSNBC of an intentional and often vile campaign of lies and misrepresentations to protect Barack Obama’s false narrative.”
Washington Post, Romney’s encouragement of Obama nuttiness, Dana Milbank, July 20, 2012. On an official Mitt Romney campaign conference call this week, former New Hampshire governor John Sununu tested the latest effort to paint the commander in chief as disloyal to his country. “I wish this president would learn how to be an American,” the Romney surrogate said. Sununu, challenged, later apologized for the words — but not the sentiment. And that’s not good enough. Sununu and Romney are legitimizing people such as Cliff Kincaid. Also on Thursday, Kincaid convened his annual conference at the National Press Club for conspiracy-minded conservatives, this one about Obama and “Radical Islam.” On the program, Obama’s photo was alongside Vladimir Lenin’s and those of radical Muslim clerics. Kincaid got right to the point: Obama was actually sired by the late author Frank Marshall Davis, identified by Kincaid as a communist pornographer. There is, Kincaid said, a “distinct possibility that Davis was Obama’s real father.” The host further informed the assembly that Davis was “Obama’s sex teacher” and that “Obama was under the tutelage of a pedophile.” Kincaid asked “what Frank Marshall Davis may have done to a young Barack Obama” and “what other terrible secrets are out there.”
Catching Our Attention on other Justice, Media & Integrity Issues
New York Times, The Program, Laura Poitras, Aug. 22, 2012 (Video). The Program: The filmmaker Laura Poitras profiles William Binney, a 32-year veteran of the National Security Agency who helped design a top-secret program he says is broadly collecting Americans’ personal data. It took me a few days to work up the nerve to phone William Binney. As someone already a “target” of the United States government, I found it difficult not to worry about the chain of unintended consequences I might unleash by calling Mr. Binney, a 32-year veteran of the National Security Agency turned whistle-blower. He picked up. I nervously explained I was a documentary filmmaker and wanted to speak to him. To my surprise he replied: “I’m tired of my government harassing me and violating the Constitution. Yes, I’ll talk to you.” Two weeks later, driving past the headquarters of the N.S.A. in Maryland, outside Washington, Mr. Binney described details about Stellar Wind, the N.S.A.’s top-secret domestic spying program begun after 9/11, which was so controversial that it nearly caused top Justice Department officials to resign in protest, in 2004. “The decision must have been made in September 2001,” Mr. Binney told me and the cinematographer Kirsten Johnson. “That’s when the equipment started coming in.” In this Op-Doc, Mr. Binney explains how the program he created for foreign intelligence gathering was turned inward on this country. He resigned over this in 2001 and began speaking out publicly in the last year. He is among a group of N.S.A. whistle-blowers, including Thomas A. Drake, who have each risked everything — their freedom, livelihoods and personal relationships — to warn Americans about the dangers of N.S.A. domestic spying.
Yahoo News, Nude photos of Prince Harry in Vegas cause royal hangover for Buckingham Palace, Dylan Stableford, Aug. 22, 2012. Nude photos of Prince Harry partying in a Las Vegas hotel room are causing another royal headache for the British monarchy. Buckingham Palace confirmed on Wednesday that the pictures of the 27-year-old naked prince playing pool in a hotel suite, posted by TMZ.com on Tuesday, are real. According to TMZ, the pictures were taken Friday after Harry and his entourage went down to the hotel bar and invited the unidentified women back to his hotel suite and engaged in a game of "strip pool." In one of the images, Harry is seen standing and covering his genitals with his hand; in another, the prince is bear-hugging a naked woman.
ABC News (Australia), Royals rocked by leaked photos of naked Prince Harry, Staff report, Aug. 22, 2012. Britain's traditionally pugnacious tabloid press is pulling its punches this morning as it deals with a self-imposed ban on publishing photos of Prince Harry frolicking naked in a Las Vegas hotel room. Two grainy photos, published on a United States gossip website, show the naked prince, who is third in line to the British throne, in compromising positions with a nude woman. The royal family has confirmed that the photos are genuine, but declined to comment further. Because the photos were taken in a private place, the voluntary press code that all UK tabloids have signed up to prohibits their publication. UK press reports say royal aides telephoned editors overnight to warn them against publishing the photos. The latest incident follows Prince Harry's poor fancy dress choice of a Nazi uniform in 2005, and a racist reference to an Asian member of his army platoon in 2009.
National Law Journal, Leaks at the Supreme Court, Todd C. Peppers, Aug. 20, 2012. In the weeks after the U.S. Supreme Court announced its ruling in the "Obamacare" case, as much attention was paid to the leaks surrounding the decision as to the decision itself. In a report that stunned official Washington, CBS reporter Jan Crawford revealed confidential information about the internal deliberations of the justices regarding the pending case — information that detailed not only Chief Justice John Roberts Jr.'s last-minute decision to join his liberal colleagues in upholding the constitutionality of the legislation, but also the lobbying efforts by the conservative justices to win back the chief justice's vote. In short, the leaked information represented one of the more significant breaches of confidentiality in the history of the modern Supreme Court.
Once journalists and legal bloggers finished digesting the leaked information, they turned their attention to debating who might have been the source of the leak. A list of possible suspects quickly emerged.
Legal Schnauzer, Child Rapist Jerry Sandusky Received a Favorable Court Ruling That Was Denied to Don Siegelman, Roger Shuler, Aug. 20, 2012. Former Penn State football coach Jerry Sandusky was granted a motion that forced prosecutors to provide specifics about charges in his child sexual abuse case. The defendants in the prosecution of former Alabama Governor Don Siegelman were denied a similar motion on charges of public corruption. What does that mean? One judge found that Sandusky was entitled to specifics about charges that essentially alleged he was a serial child rapist. Another judge found that Siegelman and codefendant Richard Scrushy were not entitled to specifics about charges that essentially sought to criminalize a standard political transaction. Does that sound fair to you? Is that what passes for justice in American courts?
OpEd News, Dana Siegelman on Her Petition for Presidential Pardon for Dad, August 22, 2012. My guest today is Dana Siegelman, daughter of former Alabama Governor, Don Siegelman. Welcome back to OpEdNews, Dana. Would you mind talking about how this case has affected you and your brother? You were regular kids who happened to have a father in public office and wham! -- suddenly your lives were turned upside down.
Yes, it was really a blow. We love our dad and had a hard time wrapping our heads around the indictment. It wasn't until he was convicted that we learned the facts of the case and realized the great injustice that had been done. I regret not making my dad explain it all to me earlier. I just knew he maintained his innocence. I didn't know it was a witch-hunt. Joseph and I went through depression when dad was sentenced the first time and dragged away to prison. We lost our faith in government, particularly the Justice Department. We worried about our mom, and we felt ashamed to really show our faces in Alabama. It helped that I lived overseas and out of state for most of it....When something really horrible happens to you, you have two choices: hide or fight. I have chosen the latter and won't give up until my dad is free and people are educated. Please help me by sharing the petition here at Change.org for a presidential pardon or commutation.
North East Mississippi Daily Journal, Judge tosses verdicts for Garner, some for Shoemaker, Patsy R. Brumfield, Aug. 24, 2012. A federal judge Thursday threw out all guilty verdicts in a hospital kickback-bribery case against Batesville businessman Lee Garner and some against Tupelo's Ray Shoemaker. The men were convicted last March in a multimillion-dollar scheme alleging they conspired to boost Garner's nurse staffing business and pay Shoemaker for his assistance as a key executive at Tri-Lakes Medical Center in Batesville. Senior U.S. District Judge Neal B. Biggers said the government was wrong to claim a federal-programs bribery through then-Panola County Administrator David Chandler, whom Garner said he paid to get his own payments in a timely manner, because Chandler was in no position to make staffing decisions to favor Garner, even though Chandler was chairman of the hospital's board. Whether the U.S. Attorney's Office in Oxford will appeal Biggers' decisions to the 5th Circuit Court of Appeals wasn't known by late Thursday.
Forbes, Hooliganism in Moscow, Bullying in Delaware: A Rose by Any Other Name, Harvey A. Silverglate and Juliana DeVries, Aug. 20, 2012. The American commentariat has been having a field day – and rightfully so – berating the Putin government of the post-Soviet Russian nation for clumsily invoking that old Soviet favorite: the “hooliganism” statute. (After all, it was Soviet dictator Josef Stalin’s secret police chief, Lavrenti Beria, who boasted “Show me the man, and I’ll find you the crime.” Hooliganism indeed has a considerable pedigree in that beleaguered land.) But back here in the States, the University of Delaware has begun using an equally vague handle – denominated a “disruptive conduct” code – to abolish what is increasingly becoming the American analogy to Russia’s “hooliganism,” namely “bullying” or “harassment.” The University of Delaware is a state university and therefore bound, in theory, to honor its students’ state and federal constitutional rights guaranteeing free speech. Yet this unacceptably vague vessel for suppressing student speech that is disfavored by the school’s administration has attracted pitifully little notice from those venues that took on the Putin government.